Unorthodox is a Bold Approach to The Ultra-Orthodox Hasidic Tradition with Anti-Semitic Clichés

In the reel world of “Unorthodox,” we are introduced to Esther, a courageous 19-year-old who embarks on a journey of self-discovery and emancipation. Fleeing from her arranged marriage and the deeply conservative Satmar community in New York’s Williamsburg, she sets her sights on a new life filled with possibilities in the vibrant city of Berlin. This Netflix series, beautifully woven with authentic Yiddish dialogue, delves into the lives of a group of people who may be unfamiliar to many, but whose compelling stories will undoubtedly resonate with viewers from all walks of life.

The Satmar community holds a profound history, founded by Holocaust survivors who sought refuge in New York after the horrors of World War II. Their lives are steeped in traditional Orthodox Judaism, and they have deliberately chosen to distance themselves from the trappings of modernity, shunning technological advancements like smartphones and televisions. Their unique language, Yiddish, a captivating blend of German, Hebrew, and English, reflects their distinctive heritage and unyielding devotion to their faith. It is essential to recognize that while the Satmar may embody some stereotypical perceptions of Jews, they represent a minority within the vast and diverse tapestry of Jewish culture, as affirmed by those from more liberal Jewish communities like the narrator, raised in the free Jewish community of Amsterdam.

Within the confines of the Satmar community’s insularity lies an enigmatic allure that captivates our curiosity, akin to the fascination many have felt towards other cloistered societies like the Amish or the followers of the Baghwan, as depicted in the acclaimed Netflix hit “Wild Wild Country.” This intrigue emanates from our innate human desire to understand worlds that seem remote and mysterious, shedding light on their customs, beliefs, and struggles. “Unorthodox” provides us with a deeply emotional and exquisitely portrayed window into this uncharted world, allowing us to empathize with Esther’s profound desire for individuality and freedom.

As we follow Esther’s extraordinary journey from a restricted existence to a world of newfound possibilities, the series reminds us of the universal human yearning for identity, autonomy, and connection. “Unorthodox” is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, showcasing the power of self-discovery and the courage it takes to forge one’s path in the face of tradition and societal norms. Through the lens of captivating storytelling and brilliant performances, this series offers us a profound insight into an otherwise hidden world, fostering understanding, empathy, and appreciation for the diverse tapestry of human experiences.

Unorthodox Deals With the Theme of Love, Freedom and Narrow Hasidim Tradition

Here, amidst the dynamic backdrop, lies a poignant contrast: Berlin was once the epicenter of suffering for her grandparents, while it also served as the catalyst for the deeply religious lifestyle of the Satmar community she hails from.

Within this juxtaposition of pain and beauty, Esty finds herself experiencing a profound rebirth at the serene Wannsee Lake. It is a powerful moment, laden with drama and emotion, fitting for the enthralling storyline of this partly American series.

As Esty embraces her new life in Berlin, the city becomes a metaphor for her evolving identity, where the past intertwines with the present. The vibrant streets and historical landmarks bear witness to her journey of self-discovery and emancipation from the confines of tradition.

In this cinematic portrayal, Esty’s newfound friendships play a crucial role in her narrative. However, some of her companions could have been more skillfully portrayed to add depth and complexity to the plot, enhancing the overall storytelling experience.

Amidst the drama and emotions that swirl around Esty’s life, the compelling backdrop of Berlin remains an ever-present force, symbolizing both her challenges and triumphs. As we follow her steps through the city’s streets, we witness the tapestry of her life being woven, capturing the essence of human resilience and the pursuit of freedom.

In this series that blends cultures and emotions, Berlin’s allure complements Esty’s transformation, forming a captivating canvas where past and present merge in a mesmerizing dance. The city itself becomes a character in this compelling tale, leaving an indelible mark on Esty’s heart as she navigates her path to self-discovery and embraces the richness of her newfound freedom.

Depiction of the Fundamentalist Hasidim Community  

They are characterized by the harsh rules that apply in their lives and by the rejection of any type of advance or modernity: their physical appearance, their way of behaving. They avoid crossing paths with people who do not practice their religion or look into their eyes; their lifestyle is simple and they do not have technology beyond what is essential.

The position of women in these communities is even more complicated: the education they receive is minimal and they only have one future: getting married (in marriages usually agreed by the rabbis of each community) and procreating, the more sons and daughters, the better, in addition to the prohibition to work and show their hair (which they usually shave after the wedding, as reflected in the series, to put on wigs) nor the legs, for which they use stockings.

Anti-Semitic Cliches in Compare to the Reality

“Unorthodox” faces criticism for depicting the Hassidic community in an unrealistic light. Critics and members of the Jewish community have raised concerns about the lack of nuance in the portrayal of this tight-knit community.

While the costumes and rituals are acknowledged as accurate by the Hasidic community, the series falls short in presenting a balanced perspective. The narrative leans heavily towards sympathizing with the main character, leaving the community somewhat caricatured in the process. In reality, the Hasidic community, like any other, comprises individuals with various shades of good and bad, a spectrum that goes beyond simplistic black-and-white portrayals.

To ensure authenticity, the “Unorthodox” team sought guidance from Hasidic actor Eli Rosen, who plays the character of Reb Yossele. His consultation aimed to ensure accuracy in depicting the community’s customs and traditions.

The series, despite featuring some clichés, doesn’t solely rely on them. Instead, it delves into a dichotomy where the Hasidic community is shown as dark and oppressive, while the Berlin environment is portrayed as vibrant, welcoming, and multicultural. This stark contrast creates a striking backdrop for the protagonist’s journey of self-discovery.

In its pursuit of compelling storytelling, “Unorthodox” treads a fine line between artistic interpretation and authenticity. The tension between the protagonist’s escape and the nuanced reality of the Hasidic community adds depth to the narrative, provoking both praise and criticism.

Ultimately, the series raises important questions about the nature of communities, individuality, and the complex interplay of cultural identities. It urges viewers to critically engage with the portrayal of religious communities on screen, acknowledging the importance of presenting diverse perspectives to foster understanding and empathy.

Representation of Women as Submissive

In the climactic finale of “Unorthodox,” Esty’s ethereal voice resonates, an emotional melody intertwining with her reminiscence of singing only with her beloved grandmother back in Brooklyn. Despite the series’ portrayal of Hasidic communities as being devoid of artistic expression, the reality unveils an evolving landscape, where women embrace increasing artistic spaces to dance, sing, and create music. In an enchanting fusion of tradition and modernity, concerts now incorporate a dash of the Hasidic spirit, celebrating the blossoming talents within these tight-knit communities.

A poignant and brave aspect of the series revolves around Esty’s tumultuous journey of self-discovery, wherein she confronts the painful reality of vaginismus, a condition rendering her intimate experiences fraught with anguish. Indeed, this portrayal reflects the poignant truth that traumatic sexual encounters are not unique to any particular milieu, transcending cultural boundaries.

However, amidst the unfolding narrative of empowerment and self-realization, some critics discern a disconcerting undertone in the way sexuality is presented. In a scene that echoes an unsettling rape encounter, the series veers dangerously close to dehumanization. This deeply troubling portrayal draws parallels with issues faced by women in the film industry, reminiscent of the stigmatization and submissiveness they endure.

Amidst the rich tapestry of “Unorthodox,” we bear witness to a multi-faceted exploration of artistic expression, identity, and sexuality. In the spirit of cinematic storytelling, the series challenges us to reflect upon the authenticity of its portrayal, underscoring the paramount importance of embracing diversity and avoiding harmful stereotypes. Such introspection paves the way for meaningful conversations and heightened empathy, illuminating the shared human experiences that traverse cultures and traditions.

As we embrace the profound lessons nestled within “Unorthodox,” we are reminded of the power of art to provoke dialogue, stimulate change, and bring forth deeper understanding. This compelling narrative stands as a testament to the transformative potential of storytelling, encouraging us to celebrate individuality, confront biases, and forge paths of compassion and acceptance.

The Danger of Generalizing  

As “Unorthodox” treads on the delicate ground of clichés, there is a genuine concern among Yiddish people that it might inadvertently perpetuate negative stereotypes about Hasidim. Despite such reservations, the series shines a spotlight on a seldom-seen community, giving voice to individuals who are often overlooked, while celebrating the courage of those who break free from tradition. For many formerly Hasidic individuals, having their stories represented, even imperfectly, on screen is a significant step towards recognition and support in their transition to a new life.

Although ultra-orthodox rabbis prohibit the use of the Internet, a growing number of Hasidic people now have access to this modern medium, breaking down barriers and opening doors to the outside world.

Modern Berlin serves as the perfect backdrop for Esty’s quest for music, art, and freedom. It’s a city pulsating with vibrant creativity, precisely what she craves. Esty’s unorthodox journey leaves a lasting impression on viewers, drawing them into her world, and capturing their attention with unexpected familiarity. For those seeking to understand the unknown and explore deeper context, the series provides a captivating entry point, stirring curiosity and reflection.

Amidst the overall positive experience of the series, Esty, the protagonist, emerges as an impeccable portrayal, captivating audiences with her unwavering spirit. Yet, it’s essential to acknowledge that the presence of anti-Semitic clichés warrants scrutiny and introspection, urging creators to approach such portrayals with sensitivity and respect.

“Unorthodox” represents a diverse perspectives, sparking conversations about identity, tradition, and the power of transformation. While it may not be perfect, its exploration of uncharted territory brings newfound visibility to marginalized voices, fostering empathy and understanding among audiences. Ultimately, it serves as a testament to the profound impact of storytelling, transcending boundaries and illuminating the shared humanity that binds us all.